Pie Bake-Off

The Oak Park Farmers' Market annual Pie Bake-Off was held on Saturday, Sept. 6, 2025.

The contest winners are listed below. Click on the names of the pies for a copy of the award-winning recipe.

• First Place: Savannah Reinhart - Midnight Orchard(PDF, 132KB)
• Second Place: Dana Stinnett - Orchard Croute d'Or(PDF, 125KB)
• Third Place: Margaret Dunham - Cozy in a Crust Homity Pie(PDF, 194KB)

1st Place winner Savannah Reinhart

 

Second Place winner Dana Stinnett

 

Third Place winner Margaret Dunham

Twelve bakers participated in the event, and after the contest extra pie was given away to Market patrons as samples.

The first-place winner not only receives bragging rights and a commemorative pie plate, but will also be invited to judge next year’s competition.

The Farmers’ Market Commission appreciates all contest entrants, as well as the Farmers’ Market volunteers and Village staff who helped to make the contest successful!